Insights›Explainable dynamic pricing: a rule overview instead of waiting
Pricing strategy

Explainable dynamic pricing: a rule overview instead of waiting

On Tuesday an item costs more than it did on Monday. Sales asks why. Nobody can answer straight away.

This problem exists regardless of what lawmakers do. Since 11 November 2026 it has become more pressing: on that day the European Commission published its proposal for the Digital Fairness Act. It is meant to replace the 2005 Unfair Commercial Practices Directive and to apply directly in every member state as a regulation. It has not been adopted yet; Parliament and Council are now negotiating.

For dynamic pricing the most important message is a calm one: dynamic and personalised prices will not be banned. Anyone who sets prices by rules, however, must be able to explain those rules. A single table is enough to do that.

What already applies today

Personalised prices are allowed. Since 28 May 2022, however, businesses selling at a distance to consumers in the EU have had to state when a price was personalised on the basis of automated decision-making. The rule comes from the Omnibus Directive; in Germany it is set out in Art. 246a § 1(1) sentence 1 no. 6 of the Introductory Act to the Civil Code (EGBGB).

This leads to the first distinction your overview has to make. Does a pricing rule follow the market, meaning demand, stock or competition? Or is it linked to the individual person, for example purchase history, device or location? Only the second case triggers the disclosure duty. The legal assessment of an individual case belongs with lawyers. Which rule falls into which category is something only your company can answer.

What this means right now

The proposal of 11 November does not change this distinction; it sharpens it. According to the analysis by the law firm Freshfields, personalised pricing would not be banned as such. The prohibition only applies where the price is based on profiling, is likely to cause harm and concerns consumers known to be minors or vulnerable. The proposal defines vulnerability more broadly than before; it can also cover financial distress, for example.

According to the same analysis, specific transparency rules for dynamic pricing are limited to event ticketing. Where customers wait in a virtual queue, Lewis Silkin reports that sellers would have to show how the price changes in real time and what the maximum possible price is. Beyond ticketing, Lewis Silkin notes that companies will have to show the full price from the start. Misleading reference prices and drip pricing are added to the list of practices that are always unfair.

Enforcement is new as well. The Commission would be able to investigate certain cases itself and impose fines. Once adopted, the regulation is intended to apply twelve months after entry into force. That is no reason to rush, but it is a clear time frame for putting your own pricing logic in order.

A rule overview on one page

You need neither a new tool nor a project. One table per product group with five columns is enough.

The first column names the trigger: what changes the price? Demand, stock, competitor price, time of day, device, customer location. The second states whether the trigger follows the market or is linked to the person. The third records the corridor: floor, ceiling and step size. The fourth names who may change the rule. The fifth records the last change: date, person, reason.

The effort stays small. Automated prices follow configured rules, so the content already sits in the configuration. It only has to be written down. Then dynamic pricing is no longer an algorithm nobody can explain, but a set of rules with clear owners. The proposal builds on a fairness by design approach. Freshfields reads this as a signal that consumer protection belongs in the design of products and processes, not in a check afterwards. For pricing, a written rule overview is a practical way to follow that idea.

How to proceed

Choose the product group where prices were questioned most often recently. Completeness comes later.

One person from pricing and one who operates the tool write down the rules together. Anything nobody can explain is flagged, not guessed.

Each trigger is labelled market or person. Anything linked to the person goes to lawyers with two questions: is the disclosure in place under current law? And could the rule affect customers who count as vulnerable?

Check the display as well. Is the full price shown from the start? Can every strike-through price be substantiated? The proposal addresses both, regardless of how the price was set.

From now on, every rule change is recorded with date, person and reason. A simple list is enough.

Then the test: take a price from three months ago and explain it. If you can, the product group is done. If you cannot, the gap shows what to do next.

What you can leave out

Being pragmatic also means not doing certain things. You do not need an impact assessment for a text that is still being negotiated. Switching tools is unnecessary as long as the rules are not written down. You do not interpret legal questions yourself. And you do not need to switch off dynamic pricing as a precaution. The proposal gives no reason to do so.

An example

The example is constructed and simplified; it is not a client case. An online retailer of accessories adjusts its prices several times a day to competitor prices and stock levels. Three people change the rules, and there is no log. At first nobody can say why an item was noticeably more expensive on two particular days.

The retailer starts with one product group. While writing the rules down, a forgotten rule from an earlier campaign surfaces: it shows existing customers on smartphones a different price. It is linked to the person and is removed. All other triggers follow market and stock. A strike-through price from the same campaign can no longer be substantiated and is removed too. From now on only one person changes the rules, and every change is on the list. The test with a price from three months ago succeeds for the period since the list was introduced. For the time before, it remains incomplete, and that is recorded openly.

Conclusion

The Digital Fairness Act does not turn dynamic pricing into a risk. It turns unexplained prices into a risk. If you keep one page per product group with triggers, corridors, owners and changes, you can answer every question: from sales, from customers and, in future, from regulators. The review then starts with a table rather than a search through the configuration.

You will find the basics in our article on dynamic pricing and on the page on e-commerce and dynamic pricing. If you would like to work through the first product group together, a conversation with Resilient Value is a sensible starting point.

This text was written with the help of AI.

Sources

Andreas Stauber

Founder & Managing Director, Resilient Value GmbH

Ready for a pricing transformation?

Let's find out in a non-binding intro call which margin potential is hiding in your pricing.

Book a call →